401kSelfStarter.comEducational Blog By Harvard Law Attorney
  • Home
  • Blog

Rollover as Business Startup (ROBS)/401k Business Financing - Reasonable Compensation Factors: How much salary can I make?

10/10/2014

0 Comments

 
401k Business Financing, Rollover as Business Startup (ROBS), salary
Rollover as Business Startup (ROBS)
Tens of thousands of small business owners have used their retirement funds to finance their business without paying taxes or penalties.   The IRS refers to this strategy as a rollover as business startup (ROBS) transaction.  The transaction entails using 401k funds to purchase stock issued by the company that operates the business.  Since the funds are not withdrawn from the 401k, the transaction does not trigger taxes and penalties.  

While the IRS has consistently acknowledged that a ROBS transaction is legitimate it has also highlighted compliance violations that it has found with respect to ROBS transactions.  One compliance concern is whether the ROBS transaction violates the Exclusive Benefit Rule which requires that all plan assets are used for the exclusive benefit of employees and their beneficiaries.  It is possible that a violation of this rule could be found if the business owner receives salary or other compensation for the services he or she performs for the business that is unreasonably high.  As such, it is prudent for the business owner to understand the factors that may be employed in evaluating the reasonableness of such compensation.

Evaluating the reasonableness of the business owner’s compensation is not a “black and white” exercise (e.g., the IRS does not maintain a schedule of reasonable salaries).  Instead, the evaluation is based on the specific facts and circumstances in consideration of several factors.   In a 2013 case the 
Tax Court considered the following factors in evaluating the reasonableness of compensation paid to the sole shareholder of a C-corporation in his role as president:   
1. Employee’s Role in the Company - Relevant considerations include:

  • The position held by the employee;

  • Hours worked;

  • Duties performed; and

  • General importance of the employee to the success of the company.

2. Comparison With Similar Companies’ Salaries

3. Character and Condition of the Company - Relevant considerations include the company’s:

  • Size;

  • Complexity;

  • Net income; and

  • General economic condition.



4. Potential Conflicts of Interest – The Court is concerned with whether a relationship exists between the employee and the company that may permit the disguise of nondeductible corporate distributions as salary expenditures.

5. Internal Consistency – This factor considers whether there is an internal inconsistency in a company’s treatment of payments to employees that may indicate that the payments go beyond reasonable compensation.

6. The Independent Investor Test: This factor considers whether an independent investor would approve of owner’s compensation package that depleted the business’s assets without appropriately paying the investor.

Takeaways:

  • A business owner who finances his business via a ROBS transaction should not receive salary or other employee compensation that is unreasonably high.

  • Evaluating the reasonableness of a salary is not a “black & white” exercise but rather requires considering the relevant facts and circumstances in light of several factors.

  • For any entrepreneur looking to finance his or her business with 401k, IRA or other retirement funds, it is imperative to work with professionals that specialize in rollover as business startup (ROBS) transactions.

Additional resources:

  • ROBS FAQS
0 Comments

    Author


    George Blower is a principal of My Solo 401k Financial LLC and also serves as the General Counsel with responsibility for providing all legal services to the organization.  

    Prior to joining My Solo 401k Financial, he served as general counsel for a subsidiary of a Fortune 500 financial services company.  

    He received his bachelor’s degree in economics at the University of Michigan in 1998 with honors. He received his juris doctorate from Harvard Law School in 2001. He is a member of the Michigan and Ohio bar associations.

    Archives

    October 2020
    September 2020
    August 2020
    June 2020
    October 2014
    September 2014
    January 2013
    October 2012
    April 2012

    Categories

    All
    401k Business Financing
    ROBS Business Financing
    Rollover As Business Startup (ROBS)
    Roth Solo 401k
    Salary
    Solo 401k
    Solo 401k Contributions Calculator
    Solo 401k Contributions Deadline
    Solo 401k Contributions Limit
    Solo 401k Contribution Types

    RSS Feed

Powered by Create your own unique website with customizable templates.
Photos used under Creative Commons from umjanedoan, Philip Taylor PT, aag_photos